As with previous issues in this series, owners of Romophone’s Gigli editions will recognise this selection, which derives from the Complete Victor Recordings Volume II 1926-28. As before the songs and arias are in chronological sequence. By now we have left behind the occasional gaucheries of his earlier discs and reach the voice in its full, unforced beauty. The top is produced and sustained with unequivocal beauty; the lower voice capable of almost baritonal extension and evenness. With electric recording came the opportunity to remake some of his earlier acoustics. Recondita armonia (his third recording of it) is genuinely thrilling and unsullied by any strictly non-musical emotionalism and his Donna non vidi mai is powerfully ardent if with a few intrusive catches in the throat. For the Drigo and Toselli songs – in the latter’s Serenata we have an unpublished second take to join the issued third - he’s joined by an unnamed violinist whose woefully slow vibrato in no way threatens Gigli’s sovereign legato. His way with light material can best be savoured in the issued sides resulting from Gigli’s visit to the New York studios on 9^th December 1926. He was in truly beautiful voice and the songs, though light and airy, are perfect vehicles for Gigli’s exceptional powers of communication, sitting perfectly for the voice. Torna amore is full of romantic declamation and Stornelli marini, the gem of the session, sees Gigli’s legato supported by a core of steel.

The duets with Titta Ruffo were not issued immediately. Ruffo’s star had waned and the voice was no longer the stentorian instrument of old, but instead now seriously frayed. In the unsatisfactory sides he made with Gigli it sounds as if Ruffo was standing farther from the microphone than his colleague – in any case the tonal imbalance between voices is considerable – and the remade sides with De Luca are a considerable improvement. Note-writer William Ashbrook prefers this later version of Boito’s Dai campi, dai prati! from Mefistofele to the 1921 acoustic but I still find it a shade too lachrymose for comfort and whilst he aspirates too much in Verdi’s Solenne in quest’ora he’s still full of warmth and a superb body of tone and makes a notable teaming with Met colleague De Luca.

Once more, those who have the Romophone discs can rest easy; the difference between transfers is minimal. The pleasure of Gigli’s voice, heard in all its resplendent youthful ardour, never pales.

Jonathan Woolf

Advertising Rates
Visitor stats
MusicWeb International
has over 21,000 Classical CD reviews on offer

Gerard Hoffnung Concerts &
The Bricklayer Story

New Releases

New Releases

MusicWeb Recommended Recordings 2008

DISCS OF THE YEAR 2007